Pour your apple cider into your pitcher or punch bowl.
Add in your caramel syrup and lightly stir
Pour in pumpkin pie spice. If you don't want this flavor to be two strong only add one teaspoon in. Stir well. The pumpkin pie spice likes to float to the top. If you can get mix it in really well it won't float it the top as much but some will still float. This is okay.
Add whatever garnishing you wish. I like to add apple slices and cinnamon sticks.